Buckle Up Peanut Butter Lovers! Our Moms are so choosy that we took all the JIF peanut butter we could find to make this baby. We creamed in about 2 lbs of America’s favorite peanut butter. Just when you thought we were done, our cooks went and laid a healthy river of JIF down the middle! This can take you from feeling like a zero to a HERO in no time!